|
Post by alf on Sept 27, 2024 11:48:03 GMT
Potentially a controversial one, but this come from a place of not understanding, rather than wanting to cause trouble. It's precisely BECAUSE its so controversial in the West, that I need to understand why. I have no affiliations here, as an Atheist who knows no (openly) practising Jews, bar one German ex colleague of my partner.
I was meaning to post about this for a while, and would have written a load of words, but watch the full version of the "Surviving October 7th" documentary" which was on BBC last night then answer one thing: Why is suppport for the Palestinians now so widespread in so much of the West, even among (for example) wealthy white christian female europeans, who consider themselves feminists? Like some I have had explaining to me that this was all somehow a plot by the Israelis. I can (sort of) understand Muslim friends of mine claiming it was some sort of false flag, a worrying number of even educated UK Muslims believe the 7/7 bombings were, such is the echo chamber of online opionions they find themselves in.
I did a history degree. This is first hand testimony, and these are first hand accounts. Listening, and watching, and making our own minds up makes a lot of sense - not absorbing the spin in social media.
Trailer for the Pramount branded version below, but find the full thing and watch it on iPlayer. I tuned in by accident, but it was so compelling it felt like it took 15 mins not 90. I felt I owed it to the victims to watch. We see the other side every day on BBC news, but this side seems somehow forgottten.The Holocaust was largely undocumented, and is now denied by many. This is the documentation, of something already being denied despite being so recent.
So, watch it, then tell me if any of you - like me - feel a shiver down your spine when you see some rich westerner carrying a Palestinian flag at a march in London....
|
|
|
Post by PetrolEd on Sept 27, 2024 12:29:06 GMT
I’m hardly the sharpest when it comes to history but enjoy the subject immensely. But even with my fisher price knowledge on Palestine, One thing that puzzles is how anyone can have a strong loyalty for either side of the conflict.
When both sides want to wipe each other off the face of the earth there is no two state solution to be found. What’s going on is absolutely horrific and probably been on the cards since Hammas took over.
I struggle to watch the killing of families on whichever side and it’s a bloody mess.
Those Brit’s waving Palestinian flags are the same people at just stop oil or whatever cause is this week’s favourite. I can’t blame Isreal for the current problems. The Uk went on a 20 year war with a number of countries because some idiots chose to fly some planes into various targets. The number 1 objective of any society is to protect its people.
|
|
|
Post by Alex on Sept 27, 2024 12:53:44 GMT
I'm similarly naive to be honest about who is right and who is wrong in all this and which side are the bad guys. Easy to see Israels response as a massively overreaction and then you hear tails of what happened on October 7th and you have to conclude that any heavily armed developed nation would be expected to do the same if they experienced a similar attack. Easy to talk about war crimes when it's not your side doing the bombing but how would you want our government to respond if the Irish popped over and massacred thousands of British citizens at a concert and took many thousands back to Ireland to be held hostage in underground tunnels? But that still doesn't make me feel in any way comfortable with the scenes coming out of Gaza. And the pager/walkie talkie attach on Hezbollah (assuming it was Israel which they have not officially confirmed) definitely seems extremely sophisticated but always likely to involve innocent casualties.
The real trouble here is that I can't see what an end game looks like other than for either side to see the other wiped off the face of the earth. A two state solution is akin to trying to get Rangers and Celtic to ground share. And that's probably a glib and very oversimplified simile and no solutions look like ever being acceptable to either side in this war. I wish I knew more so I could form an educated opinion but I know I really can't.
|
|
|
Post by Roadrunner on Sept 27, 2024 13:40:17 GMT
Based on a commentary I read a couple of days ago and I agree entirely:
Palestinians - my opinion is that whenever two republics can created safely beside each other so that both peoples can live in security and freedom can not be soon enough, long live Israel, long live Palestine - but whatever ones views on this, Hezbollah started firing missiles at civilian areas of Israel on 8 October. The missiles were fired to support the Hamas slaughter raid of 7 October. Hamas expected Hezbollah to open a second front in the north. It avoided that but instead Hezbollah fired over 8000 missiles into Israel during the last year - including the one that massacred Druze children playing football. 60,000 Israelis were forced to evacuate their homes. This is what would be called an escalation and provocation in any other time or place. Israel replied tit for tat because it was busy fighting Hamas in Gaza. Israel was last present in Lebanon 25 years ago and has not be present since.
In 2006, after the last clash between Israel and Hezbollah, UNSC 1701 ordered disarmament of armed groups including Hezbollah, with no armed forces other than UNIFIL and Lebanese military south of the Litani River. Hezbollah's forward position is in direct contravention to this.
Hezbollah is a terrorist paramilitary and Iranian vassal parastate that has captured the Lebanese republic, terrorizing and assassinating anyone who challenges it. Hence the terrified performance of its president, ministers etc. Hezbollah was a major perpetrator of the biggest mass killing of civilians in the Arab world in modern times - the slaughter of 500,000 Syrians in alliance with the Assad dictatorship, Iran and Russia. So the narrative that Hezbollah has been provoked etc etc is inaccurate. Whatever one's view of the dire Netanyahu govt. (and it is dire) Israel has no wish for a northern war; it has no presence in Lebanon and obviously after enduring the trauma and humiliation of the 7th October fiasco had no need for any more war.
No country on earth would tolerate an 8000-missile bombardment that forced it to evacuate an entire region. Israel was unable to respond earlier. Now it is doing so to end an unprovoked bombardment over many months that is sadly overdue. It is a tragedy that Israeli civilians have been terrorized all this time; it is tragic too that Lebanon, once a thriving multi-ethnic, multi-faith, multi-party system, has been sadly hijacked and captured by a ruthless terrorist vassal of Iran and that a few brutal potentates at the top of Hezbollah and the Islamic Republic of Iran are recklessly sacrificing Lebanese security and Lebanese civilians on the altar of anti-American, anti-Western democracy, anti-Israel 'resistance' and Iranian imperialism.
It is worth repeating that Lebanon has no strategic clash with Israel; Israel occupies no part of Lebanon; Lebanon has no interest in a war with Israel. In fact Lebanon and Israel should not just co-exist, but be close allies in a normal world.
Hezbollah's forward positions are in contravention of UN1701 that ordered their withdrawal north of this area. And this is entirely a war launched on 8 October by Hezbollah and Iran that benefits only Hezbollah and its masters in Iran and only destroys the innocent civlians of Lebanon and Israel and noone else. Every civilian who suffers or dies in this conflict is one civilian too many!
|
|
|
Post by Big Blue on Sept 27, 2024 16:06:32 GMT
I'll probably have to tone down my response but even so....
The support in the west is driven by the same drivers that led to the holocaust. The thinking is that Jews "have it all and are too powerful in the western world" and this is enhanced by increasingly high numbers of Muslims in the west. Let's get this bit of religious teaching straight first: Muslims want EVERYONE to become Muslim and some factions want to do so by force, with death being the only other option. Those that are moderate don't want to do the force or death bit but hope they can leave it to the others that do. Look at the fates of Christians and Druze populations in the Middle East for confirmation. Bear this in mind when you see the behaviours of Muslims in the west. More on that at that at the end.
Now we've got that bit over, Israel is home to 1.71million Muslim Arabs; there are, and always have been, Arabs on the Knesset (Israeli parliament) and their lives are seen as valid and worthy as any Jew, Christian or atheist - there are over 600 in the IDF. That's not quite the case in Muslim nations..... to put it mildly. The current "Palestinians" are actually just the Arabs that refuse to assimilate with the rest of humanity. This can be witnessed historically by the fact that Palestine was always as multicultural an area as Israel currently is but because of the refusal to assimilate it has become a segregated area (Gaza). Understand this: the other Muslim nations in the Middle East actively refuse to take in Gaza Palestinians as refugees or migrators - the wall Egypt has got up would do well for Trump on the Mexican border. Ostensibly it is there to keep Hamas at bay but "Hamas" and "Palestine" are one and the same thanks to the blind faith of the Muslim population who do and think as their religious leaders tell them.
At the other end of Israel is the Lebanese border. Lebanon is historically very cosmopolitan as pointed out above, with a large percentage of Christians, but this is under threat year on year, mainly due to the presence of Hezbollah which is effectively a state within a state. They do what they want, act like they want and persecute anyone that isn't Muslim or Muslims that don't do as they tell them to. They get away with it because the wars of the 60s and 70s were clearly unwinable so the west stayed out as much as it could (the Human League even wrote a song about it...."Who will have won when the soldiers have gone?" being the most pertinent line).
Back to that western support for what is in fact a bunch of filthy terrorist scum. The media is very careful to point out civilian deaths, almost as if these are not a factor in every war in history. That these civilians are knowingly paid to look after arms, have arms situated near to civilian public buildings to make targetting them illegal is not mentioned. Then there's the Israeli armed forces. My late father told me in the early 80s that the Israeli armed forces were the best in the world simply because they had far more actual live practice on all fronts every single day. The raining down of arms on Israel is almost never published as Israel has the Iron Dome, a defence system that keeps the enemy attacks away from the Israeli public so there are limited deaths of civilians - Israel protects its civilians; Hamas uses theirs as protection. Note that Israel didn't invent the Iron Dome to sell it on the Arms market - they developed it out of necessity. So the western public sees the mass deaths of Palestinians and (now) Hezbollah supporters and calls for Israel to be classed as evil, because they are almost never told of the ongoing daily attacks on Israel by religious fanatic nutters.
And this is the West's problem. They love a victim and protecting what they perceive as the underdog. So the trained military might of the IDF is a "bully" despite Israel being surrounded, hugely outnumbered and attacked daily. Those flag waving white kids wearing kaffirs only know that women and children are being killed, not that the states they live in and support have offered them no protection and brought attacks on them by acting out a blind religious fantasy of ruling the world with stone-aged morals.
Finally, on to Muslims in the west. The UK has a proper problem because of its history. One in having had an Empire and subsequent Commonwealth that is full of Muslims who now have "rights to Britishness" and a second in not having lived under a brutal regime in a recently close enough history. European countries are currently having no problems with their leaders, would be leaders and agitators calling for the immediate and forcible ejection of elements of society they don't want. They're more recently used to having a State that told them how to behave and now those next generation States hearing the whinges of pressure groups, be they religious, the EU itself or others, isn't having any effect. They don't care to be known as "pariah states" for their stance on migration and religious recognition if it protects their voters and the power base that comes with them. The UK is in the thrall of left wing thinking to the extent that me just thinking that it's not right when my wife tells me that she's been advised that arranging a meeting for a group after work in a pub is not inclusive enough (because apparently you MUST drink alcohol in a pub....) would get me into trouble.
Remember Churchill said "Muslims scream for equality when in the minority; but it never exists when they are in the majority." Norman Tebbit said in 2016 (that's almost a decade ago...) that Britain had a problem with Muslim communities that refused to accept the British rules, both written and unwritten. This is the issue the west needs to address now as extreme Muslims are using the flag of "equality" to gain a foothold within society and when they have the upper hand anyone else waving the equality flag will be cut down (literally in some cases).
That was the sanitised version. Whilst I was baptised in the ship's bell of HMS Collingwood and later confirmed by the Bishop of Guildford I am a non-practicing Christian, but I know which side I am on.
|
|
|
Post by Bob Sacamano v2.0 on Sept 27, 2024 18:37:20 GMT
The Israelis frequently behave like cunts, particularly the settlers in the West Bank. Unfortunately they’re surrounded by even bigger cunts.
|
|
|
Post by Big Blue on Sept 27, 2024 18:50:59 GMT
The Israelis frequently behave like cunts, particularly the settlers in the West Bank. Unfortunately they’re surrounded by even bigger cunts. Probably the shortest and best appraisal of the situation.
|
|
|
Post by franki68 on Oct 9, 2024 8:33:50 GMT
The Muslim support is understandable given that’s why the Arab world created the Palestinian issue ,they had multiple opportunities to have their own state and turned it down (given 70% of Palestinians don’t want a two state solution. And don’t want any Jews in a single state the political leaders in the west trying to force a two state solution is quite laughable) . The left wing support though is just sheer lunacy , if you can read the relevant sections from the kgb files ,these were classified kgb documents handed to the U.K. by a defector in the late 60s and they detail a propaganda campaign by the kgb to demonize Israel using tactics such as claiming it’s an apartheid state , that it’s committing genocide etc and how the kgb should exploit the fact that a large amount of academics are left wing and how to use them to create false narratives around the situation.
Media bias doesn’t help either , the bbc had to make 150+ corrections to its reporting on the conflict in the first 10 months , almost all relate to false accusations against Israel but putting an item on the six o clock news does a lot of damage but a correction in micro print will n the radio times does not undo the damage .
|
|
|
Post by johnc on Oct 10, 2024 7:34:40 GMT
The big question then has to be how do you change the thinking of Muslims so that they accept the rights of others to have different religious beliefs, behaviour and to co-exist peacefully with no interference or imposition of Muslim beliefs.
|
|
|
Post by Tim on Oct 10, 2024 8:45:17 GMT
Isn't that the same as is happening in the US with the evangelical christian morons?
Religion should be banned.
|
|
|
Post by myself on Nov 1, 2024 17:42:04 GMT
Religion is merely a form of political coercion. Bloody in extremis and inflexible in nature.
|
|