|
Post by johnc on Jan 2, 2024 13:49:41 GMT
On 31st I decided to finish work early and get home so that I could go out for a late lunch with Susan.
We were going out to Killearn to a nice coffee shop/restaurant and had to pass through Strathblane. I haven't been out on this road for a few months and was surprised to see 20mph speed limits as we entered Strathblane: what a pain in the neck. Half way along the main street they added "street furniture" a couple of years ago which makes the road a single lane for 50 yds, with a give way for the traffic travelling in the opposite direction to us. There were about 6 or 7 cars waiting at this give way for us to meander our way towards them. Had it been a 30mph limit at least 2, maybe 3 of those cars could have got round the obstruction without causing us a problem but at 20mph that was impossible. In the summer there can often be long queues at this traffic calming obstruction but I would hate to think what this 20mph limit will do in summer.
Worse still was when we got to Killearn all the roads there are now 20mph as well which feels like a snails pace - in fact we got stuck behind 2 girls on mountain bikes and there was no way to pass them without breaking the 20mph limit. These places are much visited/passed through by tourists in summer and from the look of it, I am going to have to take a mental note to use alternative routes. These roads are also very busy during the morning and evening with commuters who come in to Glasgow from the outlying villages and I can see the speed limits being Policed with regular cash counting speed traps.
God help us all if this becomes the norm.
|
|
|
Post by Boxer6 on Jan 2, 2024 19:05:01 GMT
Strathblane has been dire to drive through for a good while now, though I wasn't aware there or Killearn had gone down the 20mh route. I dare say the whole area will go that way, sooner rather than later, and I expect tourism will suffer big time.
|
|
|
Post by PetrolEd on Jan 3, 2024 10:03:39 GMT
We have the same daft 20mph limit in our town. Since they added extra planters and street furniture in Covid and have yet to take them away its hard to get to 20mph in the stop start traffic but I can't remember ever voting for this rubbish. Driving an older car it doesn't sit very well at 20mph so I will burble through town between 1st and second rather then cruising at 30mph. Its just your typical anti-car council actions.
|
|
|
Post by Blarno on Jan 3, 2024 10:36:45 GMT
I live and work on the Welsh border, so am very used to these by now. Not such am issue in the tipper, which is low geared, but can be a proper dick when towing a small digger.
|
|
|
Post by racingteatray on Jan 4, 2024 19:19:31 GMT
We have the same daft 20mph limit in our town. Since they added extra planters and street furniture in Covid and have yet to take them away its hard to get to 20mph in the stop start traffic but I can't remember ever voting for this rubbish. Driving an older car it doesn't sit very well at 20mph so I will burble through town between 1st and second rather then cruising at 30mph. Its just your typical anti-car council actions. Same with our Fiat 500, which is the perfect urban car but for the fact it really doesn't like doing 20mph, being very short-geared. By contrast, the Macan, being automatic, is much easier to pootle along in at 20mph but obviously uses far more petrol in the process. Excuse me while I go and bang my head against a hard surface... It's been wall-to-wall 20mph around us for a while now, and it's loathed by most people apart from a curious portion of the population who appear to view roads as appropriate places for children to be able to frolic. I don't actually object to 20mph on residential side streets, but I find it ridiculous that pretty much the entirety of central London is now 20mph, including wide thoroughfares like Park Lane and the Embankment.
|
|
|
Post by Big Blue on Jan 5, 2024 18:17:19 GMT
I don't actually object to 20mph on residential side streets, but I find it ridiculous that pretty much the entirety of central London is now 20mph, including wide thoroughfares like Park Lane and the Embankment. This is where I am. 20mph on the arterial roads in London is ridiculous. The times pedestrians and cyclists are about you’ll struggle to get to 30mph or there is an utter dearth of risk. All it does is piss drivers off.
|
|
|
Post by Grampa on Jan 8, 2024 12:39:40 GMT
I'm in Wales of course - there are many roads where the drop from 30 to 20 is inappropriate (barely used by pedestrians) and generally I would say that compliance on these types of roads is non-existent - it's quite a surprise to find someone actually going as slow as 20. Was probably on the way to ending 20 years of the same party in government, although all the candidates for the new first minister seem to have clocked this and are promising reviews.
|
|
|
Post by johnc on Jan 8, 2024 15:02:39 GMT
A lot of it seems to be driven by the Greens who believe it will reduce emissions when in reality for a lot of cars, they will be spinning at higher revs in a lower gear thereby generating more emissions. I understand the safety angle but timed 20mph limits outside schools and other buildings where you have vulnerable people is all that is needed.
|
|
|
Post by alf on Jan 9, 2024 11:02:55 GMT
A lot of it seems to be driven by the Greens who believe it will reduce emissions when in reality for a lot of cars, they will be spinning at higher revs in a lower gear thereby generating more emissions. I understand the safety angle but timed 20mph limits outside schools and other buildings where you have vulnerable people is all that is needed. This is perhaps the daftest part of all, as somewhere arounf 50 is the most economical speed. 30 is less economical than that, and 20 is less economical than 30. Throw in regular traffic "calming" and traffic lights, with vehicles slowing and accelerating all the time, and the impact on the environment is highly negative - especially as harmful particle emissions are half fuel, half tyres and brakes. Logical, it is not. I agree overall that 20 limits have been abused, and this reduces their potential benefit when they are used correctly. The Winchester one way system all became a 20 for example, there is already a pedestrianised high street and many side streets - the circular one way system bar one small part is not something people walk alongside. 40 is too high, 30 was perfect, 20 is a joke....
|
|
|
Post by Tim on Jan 9, 2024 13:17:39 GMT
Not just the emissions but I reckon that trying to stick to 20 is much harder than doing 30 so you spend more time watching the speedo and less looking at the road!
|
|
|
Post by johnc on Jan 9, 2024 14:50:44 GMT
Many cars also have cruise control that only works at 30mph. I probably use cruise in towns more than I do anywhere else but mine won't go as low as 20mph. Mine won't go on under 25mph so compliance is going to be extra difficult.
|
|
|
Post by Martin on Jan 9, 2024 15:17:52 GMT
Many cars also have cruise control that only works at 30mph. I probably use cruise in towns more than I do anywhere else but mine won't go as low as 20mph. Mine won't go on under 25mph so compliance is going to be extra difficult. You need the Tech Plus Pack. Mine has Innodrive and as well as all the semi-autonomous driving stuff, you can set it as low as 20mph and below 37mph it’s in queue assist mode so steers to keep you in lane and does all the work in stop/start traffic. You can switch the queue (lane) assist part off plus it’s independent of lane keep assist, so you can leave that off all the time and still have it do all the work when you’re queuing.
|
|
|
Post by Alex on Jan 10, 2024 4:39:06 GMT
The emissions issue is why I also fail to understand why so many roundabouts have 24hr traffic lights on them. I totally understand why a lot of busy roundabouts need them during peak or daytime hours but what's the point in making cars have to come to a stop and then accelerate away at 2am when the bloody thing is empty? Why not just turn them off after 10pm and until 6am? If you think about how many traffic lights there are across the country it would save a shit load of electricity too.
|
|
|
Post by johnc on Jan 10, 2024 8:31:01 GMT
The emissions issue is why I also fail to understand why so many roundabouts have 24hr traffic lights on them. I totally understand why a lot of busy roundabouts need them during peak or daytime hours but what's the point in making cars have to come to a stop and then accelerate away at 2am when the bloody thing is empty? Why not just turn them off after 10pm and until 6am? If you think about how many traffic lights there are across the country it would save a shit load of electricity too. Far too much common sense there for any Politician or Councillor to even recognise it as sensible! I have just been watching Clarkson's Farm again and it is amazing how much petty minded nastiness the Council tries to use against Clarkson to stop him doing things to make his farm more financially sustainable. They are like petulant and vindictive children who are not acting for the benefit of the whole area: it has become personal which is effectively an abuse of power in public office. As Jeremy pointed out, the Cotswolds owe much of their natural beauty to the work the farmers put in to maintaining the land. If the Council make it financially unviable then who is going to keep it as an area of natural beauty.
|
|
|
Post by Boxer6 on Jan 10, 2024 18:48:22 GMT
The emissions issue is why I also fail to understand why so many roundabouts have 24hr traffic lights on them. I totally understand why a lot of busy roundabouts need them during peak or daytime hours but what's the point in making cars have to come to a stop and then accelerate away at 2am when the bloody thing is empty? Why not just turn them off after 10pm and until 6am? If you think about how many traffic lights there are across the country it would save a shit load of electricity too. Far too much common sense there for any Politician or Councillor to even recognise it as sensible! I have just been watching Clarkson's Farm again and it is amazing how much petty minded nastiness the Council tries to use against Clarkson to stop him doing things to make his farm more financially sustainable. They are like petulant and vindictive children who are not acting for the benefit of the whole area: it has become personal which is effectively an abuse of power in public office. As Jeremy pointed out, the Cotswolds owe much of their natural beauty to the work the farmers put in to maintaining the land. If the Council make it financially unviable then who is going to keep it as an area of natural beauty.One more example of non-joined up thinking by petty-minded bureaucrats. (NB: I'm embarrassed to say it took me 4 tries to spell 'bureaucrats' correctly!!! )
|
|
|
Post by Martin on Jan 10, 2024 19:05:27 GMT
I was in the Golf today and discovered it has been fitted with the ‘Welsh Pack’, as the voodoo cruise can be set at 20mph.
|
|
|
Post by ChrisM on Jan 10, 2024 21:52:52 GMT
^ From memory, VW cruise control has worked from as low as 20mph for at least 25 years
|
|
|
Post by Tim on Jan 11, 2024 9:10:44 GMT
The first car I used cruise in much was the M5 and I was always amused by how hard it accelerated from, say, 50 to 70 when you hit 'resume'.
I was disappointed though when I tried it at 50 in 2nd gear and then slowed to 20 and hit resume, it doesn't do that.
|
|
|
Post by alf on Jan 30, 2024 10:21:19 GMT
I went to Wales on Saturday, with my brother for a walk (well, fairly epic yomp) up Pen Y Fan, and got to experience the Welsh roads nonsense at first hand. None of the locals give a shit about any of the speed limits, as usual, but the whole thing felt like a farce - 20 through some dead village when everyone is still in bed, just feels ridiculous. An indicated 35 feels extremely well behaved, and thats about as good as I got, after one trial of 20 for kicks. The amount of effort/funding that has gone into this is absurd, with the additional signs, scrubbing out of "30" signs on the road (not replaced) and so on. I'm English so what do I know, but surely Wales is not so rich they don't have better things to spend the money on? There was also a long section of duel carriageway - miles of it - with 50 limit temporary signs for no obvious reason at all, again with locals blatting through.
I had not been to the Brecons before, but have walked/MTB'd in North Wales pretty much annually for >30 years. I couldn't believe the lack of infrastructure - one local village has some toilets paid for and maintained by volunteers, that's it around the area. No visitors centre, cafe, proper car park - I've been spoiled with the excellent centre at Coed Y Brenin, and the generally better tourist infrastructure in north Wales. The overriding feeling was: F*ck off and don't come back. Considering how much tourist money must be spent on fuel, food, hotels and so on in the region, it feels like some petty minded, CO2 obsessed minority has grabbed power and is trying to make a point.
|
|
|
Post by johnc on Jan 30, 2024 11:19:55 GMT
Vocal minorities do appear to have their views imposed on the majority far too easily. I'm not saying they don't have a point sometimes but what annoys me is that instead of trying to address some of their concerns, they are given full control to impose their will on the majority.
|
|
|
Post by chipbutty on Jan 30, 2024 11:36:32 GMT
I’ve said for years that I don’t understand why the Welsh haven’t embraced their surroundings and created their version of the Lakes. They are thumbing their nose at billions of revenue.
The last time we went for pleasure was in 2013 when I took an XFR-S to Snowdon, the scenery was good, but the hotel was a dump and finding anywhere nice to eat was impossible. Went again in September for dog training (the week before the big switch over to 20 mph) and it was clearly going to be chaos. That visit made me realise that, as nice as Wales is, it isn’t as pretty as the Lakes. So I see no reason to darken their door again.
I hope the English tax payer funding is cut off asap.
|
|
|
Post by ChrisM on Jan 30, 2024 20:58:16 GMT
Reminds me of an incident many years back.... where I worked a mature member of staff and his wife went on holiday to Wales. They were in one corner shop looking around and buying some essentials for their stay when two of the locals started talking in Welsh about how English tourist were overrunning the area and ruining it for the locals. What they didn't know was that said colleague's wife was Welsh and understood, and spoke, Welsh perfectly even though her husband didn't. She apparently spouted forth in Welsh noting how the tourists brought their money into the area and kept many local businesses going, as a consequence. This left the two "natives" speechless and in a state of mild shock
|
|
|
Post by johnc on Jan 31, 2024 8:53:51 GMT
Our Council like to do everything on a budget which means they send one man and a shovel to do a job which takes weeks when three guys with a digger would sort it in a day. Probably the biggest and busiest roundabout in our area has been subjected to a "reworking" since May last year, the aim of which is to provide better access and safer passage for pedestrians and cyclists. As a consequence it has been down to one lane, had obstructions and diversions and it won't be finished till March at the earliest. The crowning glory is that they have closed the busiest exit for the last 2 months and it will be shut for at least another month. The official diversion is about 10 miles to another roundabout which already has huge queues in the morning.
However there is a rabbit run through a housing estate which brings you out beyond the road closure and I have been using that. Unfortunately there are always people in a hurry who should be taken off the road. The estate has 20mph signs up and to be fair, that is a reasonable speed given that the roads aren't wide and many of the drives have blind exits. This morning, I don't know what was going on but there was a Mercedes C Class, a Volvo XC40 and something else who were flying through the streets of this estate, going up different roads all in an effort to get ahead of each other. They must have been doing 40mph at least which is way too fast. Sometimes 20 is plenty!
|
|
|
Post by Tim on Jan 31, 2024 12:10:41 GMT
Not a 20 limit but in the save vein as John's post a few years ago our local council put a 1 mile length of foot/cyclepath alongside a dual carriageway section of the A92 and as is the way of these things it stopped randomly at a bit of verge near a roundabout. Last summer they sorted this by adding sections of foot/cyclepath to take the original up to the roundabout and then across 2 sections of verge bordering it to link up with another path heading down one of the exit roads. I reckon they added about 50-100 yards of tarmac and had to dig out the various bits of verge. This process took at least 3 months. In all the time the original mile of footpath has been there I have seen ZERO people using it
|
|
|
Post by johnc on Jan 31, 2024 14:39:49 GMT
I think the green wing of the Scottish Government is pushing an agenda that pays local authorities large amounts of money to do anything cycle/pedestrian friendly and instead of making a real difference the local authorities do whatever they can do to get the money and put in cycle paths etc which are seldom used, messing it up for the motorists - that probably makes the greens happy too.
|
|
|
Post by alf on Jan 31, 2024 15:02:29 GMT
I think the green wing of the Scottish Government is pushing an agenda that pays local authorities large amounts of money to do anything cycle/pedestrian friendly and instead of making a real difference the local authorities do whatever they can do to get the money and put in cycle paths etc which are seldom used, messing it up for the motorists - that probably makes the greens happy too. Even as a keen cyclist/runner/walker I feel a lot of the paths around here are a waste of money, and done with no real thought, and that's before I know what they cost (which I suspect is substantial). Near me there are plenty of half-arsed markings where they have made half the normal width pavement a "cycle path" but pedestrians never view it as such, I'd never cycle on them (i'd be in the road enraging you lot) as its dangerous, all they do is make people think cycling on all pavements is OK - its not. Then there are some historic wider pavements half marked as a cycle path, wide enough to use but they go from nowhere to nowhere, around a school for deaf children further out of Newbury than us. The main issue is that the three places that path terminates are a bridge in the Newbury direction (then long section with no verge/pavement on a NSL road), a major dual carriageway (that part understandably looks totally disused, I ran down in just to see where it ended, on a road you can't cycle on is the answer) and the M4/A34 services. Some like this around Thatcham are more useable but they still don't mark off the cycle part better, or make it red, people just walk across of them even when 3m wide. Then there are some new massive wide ones they have presumably spent a fortune on, but mostly they are out of Newbury in the villages the other side of the A34 for example. To get there from here on a bike you have to cross a series of NSL roundabouts where I've nearly beem knocked off, and have been beeped at, when I was exactly where I'm supposed to be going right on a roundabout by bike. So these feel like a vanity project for tiny villages that serve a handful of people only. And - British people being dickheads - the one piece of the new stuff I use regularly STILL sees people walking and pushing buggies down the cycle part, even when its a newly reclaimed part of the road, and there is still a really wide pavement separated from the cycle part by a high kerb. This isn't when its busy (its never that busy) - often when I drive past I see one person walking down the middle of the new cycle path, next to the pavement. Arseholes! I do think UK infrastructure is VERY hard to buyild this stuff on top of....
|
|
|
Post by PG on Feb 5, 2024 23:02:03 GMT
Living near the border, I've bee into Wales a few more times. I reckon that any thoeretical saving in lives through accident reduction (which has never been proved as far as I can see) will be many, many more times overtaken by increased stress related heart attacks and nervous breakdowns. It just seems to take an absolute age to go anywhere at 20. I set the limiter to 21 and that worked, but if you don't have any tech like that it is impossible to drive at 20.
On pete's point re a Welsh Lake District, too many Welsh people seem miserable as sin and hate visitors too much to ever make it work. Mrs PG had always wanted to visit Portmerion. We went and by heck it was a miserable morning. £20 per head to get in, the staff all did the "speaking in Welsh as soon as you went in a shop" thing and were pretty surley when shifting to English to serve you and the food was fucking awful. But we had lunch at Castell Deudraeth which was like a different planet of nice-ness and good food. So it could be done if they bothered.
|
|
|
Post by johnc on Feb 6, 2024 10:41:41 GMT
too many Welsh people seem miserable as sin and hate visitors too much to ever make it work. Mrs PG had always wanted to visit Portmerion. We went and by heck it was a miserable morning. £20 per head to get in, the staff all did the "speaking in Welsh as soon as you went in a shop" thing and were pretty surley when shifting to English to serve you and the food was fucking awful. Why do people spend so much time and energy being difficult to others, especially when the "others" bring money and wealth to their area.
|
|
|
Post by Tim on Feb 6, 2024 13:12:08 GMT
too many Welsh people seem miserable as sin and hate visitors too much to ever make it work. Mrs PG had always wanted to visit Portmerion. We went and by heck it was a miserable morning. £20 per head to get in, the staff all did the "speaking in Welsh as soon as you went in a shop" thing and were pretty surley when shifting to English to serve you and the food was fucking awful. Why do people spend so much time and energy being difficult to others, especially when the "others" bring money and wealth to their area. We had the same issue on the Isle of Bute. Even some of the guest house owners were surly and didn't like 'outsiders'. Mad.
|
|
|
Post by PG on Feb 6, 2024 17:05:00 GMT
When I worked in a nightclub to fund my way through university, one of the DJ's used to say at the end of his set at the end of the evening (as a joke) "you've all had a good time; we've got all your money; now fuck off home." Back in 1980 it was funny.
Sadly some (too many) people still seem to think that "give us your money and fuck off" is a suitable way to run any service or tourist business.
|
|